Tragedy at Happy Cat Sanctuary: Founder and Dozens of Cats Killed in Long Island Fire

A heartbreaking loss

Authorities confirmed that a man was found dead inside the home along with a significant number of deceased cats. The property, widely known in the community as the Happy Cat Sanctuary, reportedly housed over 100 cats.

"During the course of the firefighting operations, it was discovered that there was a deceased male inside the dwelling, along with numerous deceased cats," said Suffolk County Chief of Detectives Bill Doherty.

While the exact number of deceased and surviving animals has not yet been confirmed, officials estimate that the property was home to more than 100 cats. The Town of Brookhaven and the Suffolk County SPCA responded to the scene to rescue the surviving animals.

A founder who gave everything for his animals

Though the victim’s identity has not been officially released, neighbors say the man was Chris Arsenault, the founder of the Happy Cat Sanctuary. Witnesses reported seeing him repeatedly running into the burning home to rescue cats before disappearing inside for the final time.

"He kept going back in and out of the house to get cats out, and then he went in and he didn't come out," said Lisa Jaeger, a volunteer at the sanctuary.

Chris Arsenault was known in the community for his unwavering dedication to animal welfare. He reportedly began rescuing cats after the tragic death of his son in a motorcycle accident two decades ago.

Survivors and ongoing rescue efforts

Frank Floridia of Strong Island Animal Rescue League said that approximately 150 cats remained in outdoor enclosures built on the property. “They are safe, they are hopefully not injured,” he added.

The Suffolk County homicide and arson squads are currently investigating the incident. The cause of the fire and the victim’s death have not yet been determined.

As news spread, several animal lovers arrived at the scene with carriers, offering help to relocate and care for the surviving cats.