Animals That Feel the Slice of the Knife: Inside America's Slaughterhouses
The hidden cruelty within factory farms is no secret, but what happens during the slaughtering process may be even more disturbing. "If everyone had to work just one day inside a meatpacking plant, these slaughterhouses would not exist," says Ian Packer, 36, an undercover investigator who documented horrific practices at Manning Beef LLC in Los Angeles.
Animals Butchered Alive?
Packer’s videos captured animals seemingly alive during slaughter. "I looked into the eyes of cows who felt every slice as their ears were cut off and faces skinned. Workers held them down while they gasped for air and struggled in pain," recounted Packer, whose investigation was conducted for the nonprofit Animal Outlook. "Watching these animals butchered alive will haunt me forever."
The majority of livestock are not butchered alive, and Manning Beef’s owner denies any such occurrences at his facility. However, the disturbing footage has reignited the debate over claims of "humane slaughter."
Reduced Oversight Raises Alarms
The situation risks deteriorating further due to recent deregulation by the Trump administration, significantly decreasing federal oversight. Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins recently stated, "We are cutting unnecessary red tape, empowering businesses to operate more efficiently." While efficiency may increase, critics fear it also raises the risk of animals being slaughtered improperly due to faster processing lines and reduced inspections.
Animals are supposed to be stunned and rendered insensible before slaughter, but Packer claims to have witnessed animals being processed while conscious.
Industry Denial vs. Reality
Anthony DiMaria, owner of Manning Beef, rejects these accusations. "There's no way an animal can be hoisted up alive," DiMaria argues, noting federal inspectors could shut down operations if violations occur. However, inspectors previously suspended the plant in 2022 after witnessing incomplete slaughter on multiple occasions.
Veterinarian Lester C. Friedlander, an expert in slaughterhouse inspections, reviewed Packer’s videos and confirmed many animals appeared conscious and in pain. Meanwhile, livestock-handling specialist Temple Grandin had mixed interpretations, highlighting the complexity in distinguishing reflexes from actual suffering.
Questioning Humane Standards
The Meat Institute maintains that 96 percent of animals are effectively stunned with one shot; however, this leaves 4 percent potentially subjected to severe pain. Critics argue this is an unacceptable margin for error, given the scale: about 300 animals slaughtered per second in the U.S.
Animal welfare may seem peripheral given the nation's current challenges, but Nicholas Kristof insists it demands attention. "One day we will wonder how we allowed such suffering on this scale," he asserts.
A Call for Better Regulations
Improved laws and inspection protocols have reduced animal suffering, but more can be done. Continuous oversight during stunning would cost less than a fraction of a cent per pound of meat and significantly reduce cruelty.
"If you torture one animal, you're arrested and labeled a psychopath. But if you systematically abuse millions, you're praised for business acumen," Kristof reflects, highlighting a disturbing paradox in our food system.
.jpg)
.png)
